Stuff your stockings with EDRA of MI swag – shop mugs, clothes, stickers, & more!

Economic Development Responsibility Alliance
Economic Development Responsibility Alliance
  • Home
  • Issues
    • Bad Economic Development
    • AI Data Centers
    • Semiconductors
    • Industrial Wind & Solar
    • EV Batteries
  • Communities
    • Saline Township
    • Howell Township
    • Ypsilanti Township
    • Augusta Charter Township
    • Kalkaska
    • Lowell
    • Frenchtown Township
    • Dundee Village
    • Pavilion Township
    • Dorr and Gaines Townships
    • Dowagiac
    • Grayling
    • BESS Groveland
    • BESS Columbia
    • Marshall
    • Mundy
    • Detroit
    • Big Rapids
    • Plymouth & Northville
    • Eagle
    • Augusta Township
    • Vernon/Shiawassee
  • Alternative Development
  • Shop
  • About Us
    • About EDRA MI
    • Rural Neighbors
    • City Neighbors
    • Annual Report 2023-2024
    • Contact
  • Get involved
    • Take action
    • Scientific research
    • Newsletter
    • Donate
  • Blog
  • More
    • Home
    • Issues
      • Bad Economic Development
      • AI Data Centers
      • Semiconductors
      • Industrial Wind & Solar
      • EV Batteries
    • Communities
      • Saline Township
      • Howell Township
      • Ypsilanti Township
      • Augusta Charter Township
      • Kalkaska
      • Lowell
      • Frenchtown Township
      • Dundee Village
      • Pavilion Township
      • Dorr and Gaines Townships
      • Dowagiac
      • Grayling
      • BESS Groveland
      • BESS Columbia
      • Marshall
      • Mundy
      • Detroit
      • Big Rapids
      • Plymouth & Northville
      • Eagle
      • Augusta Township
      • Vernon/Shiawassee
    • Alternative Development
    • Shop
    • About Us
      • About EDRA MI
      • Rural Neighbors
      • City Neighbors
      • Annual Report 2023-2024
      • Contact
    • Get involved
      • Take action
      • Scientific research
      • Newsletter
      • Donate
    • Blog
Donate

  • Home
  • Issues
    • Bad Economic Development
    • AI Data Centers
    • Semiconductors
    • Industrial Wind & Solar
    • EV Batteries
  • Communities
    • Saline Township
    • Howell Township
    • Ypsilanti Township
    • Augusta Charter Township
    • Kalkaska
    • Lowell
    • Frenchtown Township
    • Dundee Village
    • Pavilion Township
    • Dorr and Gaines Townships
    • Dowagiac
    • Grayling
    • BESS Groveland
    • BESS Columbia
    • Marshall
    • Mundy
    • Detroit
    • Big Rapids
    • Plymouth & Northville
    • Eagle
    • Augusta Township
    • Vernon/Shiawassee
  • Alternative Development
  • Shop
  • About Us
    • About EDRA MI
    • Rural Neighbors
    • City Neighbors
    • Annual Report 2023-2024
    • Contact
  • Get involved
    • Take action
    • Scientific research
    • Newsletter
    • Donate
  • Blog
Donate

Take Action against Wind, Solar, and BESS in your community

Action checklists and strategies for fighting utility-scale wind, solar, and battery energy storage systems in your local community.

An Action Checklist

Download this handy guide for grassroots organizers:

Download PDF

Request our Strategy Guide for Fighting Wind, Solar, and BESS

Request a copy

what you should know about PA 233

PA 233 and the battle for local zoning of wind, solar, and BESS

Michiganders have been fighting for local zoning control since 2023, and the fight now rages on in countless communities across Michigan. 


In November 2023, Michigan’s state legislators approved a set of laws which aimed to strip local townships and counties of their rights to regulate zoning for wind, solar, and BESS, and to hand it to a Governor-appointed state agency: the Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC). The laws went into effect as Public Act 233 (PA 233) in November of 2024. Now, if townships or counties don’t have zoning ordinances that allow for wind and solar development, the developers can take their permit applications directly to MPSC for approval. MPSC also regulates energy utility rates. In fall of 2024, an appeal representing over 70 Michigan municipalities was filed against PA 233, stating the laws’ overreach is unconstitutional.


So what does this mean for Michigan communities who don’t want their farmland to disappear beneath energy fields?


It means that the state administration has made it more difficult for local communities to block these developments at the local level. It means that there is no one magic bullet communities can use to stop these. Every fight is different.


On the flip side, it also means that MPSC has bitten off more than it can chew, in permitting and regulating these developments. MPSC is getting buried in permit requests. What’s more, because PA 233 is a new law, there is no legal precedent for fighting it. In other words: Michigan communities fighting PA 233’s wind and solar zoning in court are setting the standard for how this law is enforced. And so far, PA 233’s laws are not standing up well in local courts. 


Michigan is the wild west for wind, solar, and BESS right now, legally speaking, and Michigan’s grassroots communities have the opportunity to take their local rights back through strategic action.

what should I do?

Start by finding answers to these questions:

1) Has your township/municipality passed any ordinances to regulate utility-scale wind/solar? 

This will have a big impact on your fight. If the townships have passed ordinances which regulate wind/solar/BESS, then it’s possible developer applications can be denied or challenged in court locally. If there are no local zoning ordinances regulating these, developers will apply directly to Michigan Public Service Commission (MPSC) for permits, and your community will be dealing directly with state agencies and courts.


If your township has passed an ordinance, what is it? Is it:

  • a Compatible Renewable Energy Ordinance (CREO), as recommended by MPSC and the new PA233 law
  • a workable ordinance,
  • an unworkable ordinance, or
  • a zoning ordinance passed before 2024?


Find the ordinance and become familiar with its contents, and how it was created.


2) What stage is the project in right now? 

  • Has the developer applied for permits? 
  • Who currently owns the land? A local, or the developer?
  • Is it being funded by any grants or subsidies? (this is typically the case for out-of-state developers, less so with Consumers Energy and DTE)


3) What are the details of the project?

  • What is the land currently–farmland? Wetlands? Forest? (Use USFW’s Wetlands Mapper tool)
  • Who are the site’s neighbors–residential? Commercial? Agriculture? Are there any vulnerable human populations or habitats that will be affected? (use the EPA’s Environmental Justice Screening Tool to identify vulnerable areas)
  • Is there a site plan?
  • Is there an Environmental Impact Study (EIS)? Note: An Environmental Assessment (EA) does not provide the depth of information that an EIS does, nor does it meet the same threshold for federal regulation.

Next, take steps to organize:

  • Connect with local residents who oppose the project; form working groups on social media and private networks.
  • Speak with all your elected officials, from your township to Washington DC.
  • Speak with experts–on fire, public health, biology, soil, economics, real estate, zoning and enlist their expert opinions.
  • Speak with local public health and safety leaders–Fire Chiefs, Sheriffs, School Boards, Health and Human Services Directors–and express your concerns.
  • Host town hall meetings with your neighbors; invite guest speakers.
  • Collectively decide on a path of action. Will your community pursue legal action? Will you rely on intervener funds? Will you build a large grassroots campaign?
  • Develop informational one-pagers and other resources to share; include actions people can take.
  • Reach out to local media, and consider writing an op-ed to a local or state newspaper.
  • Connect with other communities fighting similar battles; share best practices.
  • For more detailed recommendations, you can download our Community Action Checklist here:

Download Action Checklist

What’s the best strategy for fighting these destructive energy projects?

No two communities face the exact same problem, so every community’s solutions are different. There are no one-size-fits-all remedies. In fact: different local groups fighting these have some very different opinions on the best approach. There are a number of different approaches communities can take, and none of them are ideal. For example, your community could:

  • Adopt a Compatible Renewable Energy Ordinance (CREO), as MPSC recommends
  • Adopt an incompatible ordinance and deny permits
  • Use intervener funds to defend permit denial against MPSC
  • Do primary research and get expert opinions
  • Conduct a strong grassroots public awareness campaign
  • Do a combination of any number of these strategies
  • Follow other strategies we can’t discuss here


There are pros and cons to each of these. Only you and your neighbors can know which strategies will work best for your community.


To help you understand your options, we’ve created a Strategy Guide. Because it contains sensitive strategy information for grassroots organizers, we can’t post it publicly–but we’re happy to share it with you. Just drop us a quick line requesting our Wind/Solar/BESS Strategy Guide.

request the guide

Oshtemo Township grassroots organize communities battling BESS

Read their resources and action items.

Learn more

Connect with other communities fighting wind and solar!

Join us on Facebook

Join our email newsletter

get the latest news and action items:

  • Alternative Development
  • Shop
  • About EDRA MI
  • Contact
  • Take action
  • Newsletter
  • Donate
  • Blog

EDRA of MI

Copyright © 2023 EDRA of MI - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

Have you subscribed?

Get the latest news and action items by subscribing to our newsletter.

sign me up

This website uses cookies.

This is an annoying banner letting you know we use Google Analytics. Cool?

nopeyep