A Clean Energy Land Use Specialist from University of Michigan made a presentation at Groveland Township, in which she listed pros and cons of the BESS site. “Local Benefits” were almost entirely financial, while “Local Concerns” included visual impacts, sound, environmental impacts, and fire and explosion risk.
The presentation made it clear that money is the only motivating factor for this development, and that money would be made at the expense of the health, safety, and ecological integrity of the area.
When questioned by township residents why existing brownfield sites aren’t being considered for the project, Vesper Energy employee, EJay Fyfe, stated:
"This is the site we’ve identified. You know, we're a business. I think it a lot of the times, it gets lost in this that we're maybe like a nonprofit or something, kind of coming in to try to save the environment, but the reality is that we're a power producing business and those sites, uhm, don’t work, those sites don’t work for this project”.
Another Vesper employee clarified, regarding the available brownfield sites: “They’re too small, there’s not the available injection capacity that we have here, there would be significant remediation efforts…”
Remediation = cost.
Groveland Township Supervisor Robert DePalma is in is in favor of the project because of the $1.5M Renewable Ready Community Award grant opportunity with EGLE. Despite all the available evidence, DePalma states the project:
“Appears to be a very good way to do safe installations, protect the integrity of the community, and these things tend to be very noninvasive.” The greenfield site, he says, “is about the best site for this that I can think of if this goes through.”